Spiced Coffee Liqueur Recipe: A Homemade Holiday Gift

Spiced coffee liqueur makes a warm, buttery homemade gift for the holidays. This blend of coffee, rum, vodka, and spices brings real holiday spirit. Cinnamon, orange, and a whisper of cayenne round out the flavor. Bottle the batch early, and let the blend rest before gifting. A homemade bottle feels far more personal than a store-bought one.

Make and bottle the liqueur before or after Thanksgiving for a Christmas gift. This drink is for adults 21 and over, so please enjoy responsibly. Serve the liqueur over ice, or stir a splash into coffee.

Spiced Coffee Liqueur at a Glance

Here are the key details for making spiced coffee liqueur before you begin.

A strong dark roast creates the boldest spiced coffee liqueur. Let the finished bottles rest for at least three weeks before opening for the smoothest flavor. Browse our premium whole bean coffee to get started.. Browse our premium whole bean coffee to start.

Ingredients

Everything you need to make homemade spiced coffee liqueur.

• 1 qt strong, hot coffee
• 1 cinnamon stick
• 1 sprig rosemary
• 2 sprigs fennel greens
• 1 stem fresh mint, about 6 to 8 leaves
• Peel of 1 large orange
• 2 cayenne peppers, cored and seeded
• 2 cups granulated sugar
• ½ cup light brown sugar
• ½ cup dark brown sugar

• 2 parts coffee syrup
• 1 part dark rum
• 1 part vanilla vodka

How to Make Spiced Coffee Liqueur

Make the spiced coffee syrup first, then blend and bottle. The syrup keeps until you are ready.

1. Peel the skin from one orange with a vegetable peeler, avoiding the white pith.
2. Place the orange peel, spices, and herbs in a non-reactive saucepan.
3. Pour the hot coffee over the spices and let the mix steep for 30 to 45 minutes.
4. Strain the coffee through a mesh strainer or cloth, then return the liquid to the pan.
5. Set the pan over low heat and stir in all three sugars.
6. Stir gently until the sugar fully dissolves.
7. Raise the heat to medium and bring the mixture to a simmer.
8. Lower the heat and simmer until the syrup thickens and reduces, about 30 to 45 minutes.
9. Cool the syrup to room temperature.
10. Store the syrup in a covered jar until you are ready to bottle.

1. Mix one part dark rum with one part vanilla vodka in a large, non-reactive container.
2. Add two parts coffee syrup and stir gently to blend.
3. Funnel the liqueur into clean bottles, leaving half an inch of headroom.
4. Cork or cap the bottles tightly.
5. Store the bottles in a cool, dark place for at least three weeks.

Tips and FAQ

Brew the coffee double strength so the flavor holds through the sugar and spirits. Taste the syrup before you bottle, and adjust the spice. Label each bottle with the date you blended the batch. Chill a bottle before serving for a smoother pour. Use small bottles for easy party favors. Prefer a simpler version? See our classic coffee liqueur recipe.

Brew a strong, fresh dark roast for a bold base. The coffee flavor should stand up to the rum and vodka. Freshly ground beans give the cleanest result. See our roast levels guide to choose yours.

Sealed and stored cool and dark, the liqueur keeps for months. The flavor smooths and deepens over time. Chill after opening for the best taste. Keep the bottles upright to protect the corks.

The rest lets the coffee, spices, and spirits marry. A longer rest gives a smoother, rounder flavor. Three weeks is the minimum for a balanced result. A gentle shake once a week helps the flavors blend.

Add or drop herbs to suit your taste. More cayenne brings heat, while extra orange adds brightness. Steep longer for a bolder, spicier syrup. Toast the whole spices first for a deeper aroma.

Bottle the liqueur in clean glass bottles with tight corks. Add a ribbon and a handwritten tag with the date. A wax seal adds a rustic touch. Store the gift cool and dark until you hand the bottle over.

Fresh Coffee to Pour

Pour with coffee worth tasting. Browse our premium whole bean coffee, roasted fresh and shipped within 1 to 2 business days.

Subscribe with the Blackout Coffee Club and save 19% on every order. Hosting a big table? Our bulk coffee keeps the carafe full.

Make your own base with our coffee liqueur guide, or plan a spread with our baking with coffee recipes.

Short on time? Our coffee pods brew a quick, strong cup for any of these drinks.

Learn how we source and roast on our About Blackout Coffee page. Follow us on Instagram and Facebook.