3 Roast Levels: How to Choose?

March 19, 2012

3 Roast Levels:  How to Choose?

Are you taking your first journey into gourmet coffee beyond Starbucks, Dunkin Donuts and other supermarket coffee?

Congratulations, there’s a world of great tasting coffee available.

Maybe the first and easiest choice you could make is what roast level to purchase: light, medium or dark roasted coffee.

What’s the taste difference?

Basically the darker the roast the more coffees taste similar.  The reason is that the darker you roast coffee, the more dominant is the burnt / charred flavor.  That’s not always a bad thing - it’s an often desirable characteristic that adds another layer of flavor to a coffee.  It’s a variable that skilled coffee roasters control.

Light Roasted coffee brings out the most origin character of particular coffees.  You’re better able to taste the difference between a Colombian (full body, some floral notes) and say a Kenyan (bright wine acidity) and a Sumatran (earthy and mossy). Not all coffees are great light roasted, some have undesirable tastes like peanuty, vegetabley,  cocoay. Often coffees that are light roasted don’t taste balanced (meaning equal amounts of body, acidity and fruitiness. The problem is that some customers just don't like light roasted coffee because it can taste extreme.  Too much citrus. Too much floral.  Not necessarily balanced.  Visit our selection of Light Roasted Coffees and Light/Medium coffees here.

Medium Roasted is a compromise that often brings out the best flavors in coffees that have begun caramelization but don’t yet have any burnt or chocolately darkness to them.  This roast level often brings out a balanced complete coffee with lots of possible flavors: citrus, fruit, berry, acidity.  Our full selection of Medium coffees are available here

Dark Roasted coffee can give you bold, rich, darkness.  In unskilled hands or with inexpensive green beans it can give you charred, acrid or burnt flavor  (to be honest some customers like this flavor). Tastes converge towards chocolatey darkness, and there is little in the way of floral, berry, fruit, citrus.   Those flavors have been burnt off or overshadowed by the flavor of full caramelization.  This can taste like cowboy coffee:  dark, rich, stewy.  Sumatrans are great in this roast range.  It’s an industry secret that when you have beans you’re trying to use up rather than putting them on sale you put them into a French Roast.  Almost anything tastes alike in a French Roast  (sorry, coffee roaster friends).  Our selection of dark roasted beans can be found here, otherwise, if you want something in between medium and dark, here is a list

What roast level is best for espresso? Trick question, right?  There are basically 4 finer roast levels usually for espresso, all falling under medium-to-dark:  Full City Roast, Vienna Roast, French Roast and Italian Roast.  The pressure of espresso extraction tends to work best with these darker roasts because the sugar in the beans has been fully caramelized, boosting flavor.  We've a coffee that is well-suited for espresso which is called Pitch Black Espresso.

Just note that specialty coffee roasters use many different terms for roast levels that full under these 3 main categories.  From lightest to darkest there's a City Roast, Full City, Vienna, French Roast, Italian Roast, Spanish Roast, Turkish coffee roast (charrrred). 

If you’re a beginner diving into gourmet coffee, what should you try?  

Our gourmet coffee suggestions:

Do you like dark rich cowboy coffee that is full body, bold and rich?  Then bypass everything and just get some dark roasted coffee.

Do you like a balanced coffee with potentially elements of citrus, fruit, berry, acidity, and a complete range of flavors?  Try medium roast coffees.

Do you want to taste wildly different coffees at the extremes?  Try Light Roast perhaps from say 3 different regions - Central America, Africa (esp. Ethiopia and Kenya) and islands (Sumatra, Hawaii).  One coffee may taste wildly lemony, another buttery, another earthy.  

But of course read the descriptions under the coffees at Blackout Coffee, as each coffee’s uniqueness comes out at different roast levels.

Blackout Coffee

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The Reading Room

5 Simple Steps To Maintain and Clean Your Baratza Encore Grinder
5 Simple Steps To Maintain and Clean Your Baratza Encore Grinder

October 26, 2017

Read More
Your Ultimate Coffee Glossary: A Helpful List of Terms
Your Ultimate Coffee Glossary: A Helpful List of Terms

September 27, 2017

Here are some common terms you’re likely to run into whether you’re fresh on the coffee scene or just dabbling in a new area of interest.
Read More
3 Women Pioneers in the Coffee Roasting Business
3 Women Pioneers in the Coffee Roasting Business

August 02, 2017

Read More

GET 10% OFF YOUR FIRST ORDER